The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies: A Critical Review

Omar Yusuf

4 min read

Post on May 13, 2025

4.5

Share

Visual Spectacle and Effects

The Scale of the Battle

The titular Battle of Five Armies is undeniably the film's centerpiece, a breathtaking display of CGI and visual effects. The sheer scale of the conflict is staggering, dwarfing even some of the epic battle sequences in Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy. The armies clash in a chaotic ballet of swordplay, magic, and monstrous creatures, creating a visceral and immersive experience for the viewer. Keywords like "CGI," "special effects," "visual effects," and "battle sequences" are integral to understanding the technical achievement of this film.

• Impressive Visual Moments: The fiery dragon Smaug's final moments, the devastating warg charges, and the ingenious tactical maneuvers showcase the film's technical prowess.
• Comparison to The Lord of the Rings: While not quite reaching the emotional depth of Helm's Deep or Minas Tirith, the Battle of Five Armies surpasses them in sheer scale and scope of destruction.
• Effectiveness of CGI: The CGI, while occasionally noticeable, generally serves to enhance the intensity and chaos of the battle, immersing the viewer in the brutal reality of the conflict.

Character Development and Arcs

Thorin's Transformation

Thorin Oakenshield's character arc forms the emotional core of The Hobbit: The Battle of Five Armies. His descent into dragon sickness and his eventual redemption provide a compelling narrative. The film successfully portrays his internal struggle between his greed for the treasure and his loyalty to his kin. Keywords such as "character development," "arc," "Thorin Oakenshield," and "redemption" aptly describe this crucial aspect of the film.

• Key Scenes: His confrontation with Bilbo, his courageous stand against Azog, and his final moments of self-sacrifice all highlight his internal conflict and eventual heroic act.
• Book vs. Film: While the film streamlines Thorin's arc, it remains largely faithful to the spirit of the book, capturing his complex and ultimately tragic nature.
• Richard Armitage's Performance: Armitage delivers a nuanced performance, conveying Thorin's internal turmoil with both subtlety and power.

Other Key Characters

While Thorin's arc dominates, other characters receive less development. Bilbo's journey feels somewhat sidelined in the face of the epic battle, and Gandalf's role, while important, lacks the same depth of exploration found in The Lord of the Rings. Legolas's presence, bordering on fan service, feels out of place in the broader narrative.

Plot and Pacing

A Rushed Narrative?

A common criticism of The Hobbit: The Battle of Five Armies is its rushed pacing. The attempt to cram a significant amount of plot into a single film results in some underdeveloped scenes and a sense of narrative whiplash. Keywords like "plot pacing," "narrative structure," and "film pacing" encapsulate the concerns surrounding this aspect of the film.

• Rushed Scenes: The romances and some key character interactions feel underdeveloped, sacrificed at the altar of the epic battle sequences.
• Adherence to Source Material: The film deviates significantly from Tolkien's book, which contributes to a feeling of disconnect for some viewers.
• Comparison to Previous Films: Compared to the previous Hobbit films, Battle of Five Armies feels noticeably faster-paced, leaving little room for character breathing space.

Thematic Elements and Legacy

Exploring Themes of Greed and Redemption

The Hobbit: The Battle of Five Armies successfully explores themes of greed, loyalty, and the cost of war. These themes are woven into the narrative fabric, enriching the larger story. Keywords such as "themes," "greed," "redemption," "loyalty," and "war" are central to understanding the movie's deeper meaning.

• Visual and Narrative Presentation: The contrast between Thorin's initial greed and his eventual selflessness powerfully illustrates the film's core themes.
• Connection to Tolkien: The film’s themes resonate with larger Tolkienian themes explored in The Lord of the Rings, creating a thematic consistency across the extended cinematic universe.
• Success in Conveying Themes: The film mostly succeeds in portraying these themes, though the rushed pacing sometimes hinders the emotional impact.

Its Place in Tolkien's Legacy

The Hobbit: The Battle of Five Armies, despite its flaws, remains a significant entry in the cinematic adaptation of Tolkien's works. It concludes Peter Jackson's Hobbit trilogy and finds its place alongside the Lord of the Rings trilogy in popular culture.

Conclusion

The Hobbit: The Battle of Five Armies is a visually stunning film with a powerful central performance from Richard Armitage. However, its rushed pacing and underdeveloped supporting characters detract from its overall impact. While the battle sequences are breathtaking, the narrative sometimes feels sacrificed for spectacle. Ultimately, it provides a satisfying, if somewhat flawed, conclusion to the Hobbit trilogy. What are your favorite scenes from The Hobbit: Battle of Five Armies? Let us know your thoughts on The Hobbit: The Battle of Five Armies in the comments below!