Disney's Improved Approach To Snow White In Future Live-Action Adaptations

Omar Yusuf

5 min read

Post on May 14, 2025

4.8

Share

Addressing the Problematic Elements of the Original Snow White Story

The original Snow White fairytale, while charming, contains several problematic elements that require careful consideration in any modern adaptation.

The Damsel in Distress Trope

Snow White's passivity and complete reliance on male characters for rescue are major sticking points. This outdated portrayal of female helplessness needs a significant overhaul.

• Outdated Portrayal: The original narrative presents Snow White as a passive character, waiting for a prince to rescue her. This is a harmful stereotype that reinforces the idea of female weakness and dependence.
• Alternative Narratives: Future adaptations should empower Snow White with agency and self-reliance. She could actively participate in her own rescue, demonstrate resourcefulness, and showcase skills that contribute to her survival.
• Successful Retellings: Consider successful retellings like Angela Carter's feminist reimagining of fairy tales, which offer examples of how to subvert traditional tropes and empower female characters. Modern audiences respond to proactive heroines who drive their own narratives.

The "Evil Queen" Archetype and its Modern Interpretation

The Evil Queen, while iconic, often falls into harmful stereotypes. A more nuanced portrayal is needed.

• Beyond Simple Jealousy: Instead of simply portraying her as a villain driven by jealousy, exploring deeper motivations would add complexity. Perhaps she’s driven by societal pressures, ambition, or a fear of losing power.
• Backstory and Depth: Developing a compelling backstory for the Queen can humanize her, even if she remains an antagonist. This creates a more engaging and morally ambiguous character.
• Ambition vs. Malice: Framing the Queen's actions as stemming from ambition or a struggle for survival, rather than pure malice, provides a more relatable and less stereotypical antagonist.

The Prince's Role and its Modern Counterpart

The Prince's role in the original story is also problematic. A modern adaptation needs to address this.

• Consent and Healthy Relationships: The Prince's actions, particularly his immediate kiss upon waking Snow White, are problematic in a modern context. This raises significant concerns around consent and healthy relationships.
• Supportive Role: The Prince could be reimagined as a supportive friend or ally, working alongside Snow White rather than rescuing her. This highlights a more egalitarian dynamic.
• Removing the Prince: One option is removing the prince entirely, allowing Snow White's agency and strength to take center stage without reliance on a male savior. This would best empower Snow White's narrative.

Modernizing the Narrative for Contemporary Audiences

Updating the narrative for a modern audience is crucial for any successful reimagining of Snow White.

Empowering Snow White as a Protagonist

Snow White needs to be a fully realized protagonist, not just a passive recipient of events.

• Proactive Goals: Give Snow White clear goals beyond merely avoiding the Evil Queen. She could be pursuing a specific ambition, solving a problem, or fighting for a cause.
• Skills and Talents: Equip Snow White with skills and talents beyond simply being beautiful. She could be skilled in combat, crafts, or problem-solving.
• Significant Choices: Snow White's choices should impact the narrative's direction, showcasing her agency and decision-making abilities. She actively shapes her destiny rather than simply reacting to it.

Diversity and Inclusive Casting

Diverse casting is essential for reflecting the diversity of modern society.

• Ethnic Backgrounds: Casting actors from various ethnic backgrounds broadens the appeal and promotes inclusivity.
• Audience Engagement: Diverse representation resonates with a wider audience, fostering a sense of belonging and increasing engagement.
• Successful Examples: Look at successful diverse casting choices in other Disney projects as proof of concept and audience appeal. This demonstrates that inclusivity enhances the storytelling experience.

Re-evaluating the Magic Mirror and its Function

The magic mirror plays a significant role, but its function could be reimagined.

• Alternative Conflict: Explore other sources of conflict and narrative tension that don't rely solely on the magic mirror.
• Altering or Removing the Mirror: Consider removing the mirror or changing its function, perhaps transforming it into a metaphor for societal pressures or self-perception.
• Metaphorical Interpretation: The mirror could be reframed as a symbol of self-doubt or societal expectations that Snow White must overcome.

Learning from Successful Retellings and Adaptations

Learning from past successful retellings of fairy tales can inform a better Snow White adaptation.

Analyzing Successful Reimaginings

Examining other successful adaptations of classic fairy tales provides valuable insights.

• Film and Literature: Analyze films and literature that have successfully modernized classic fairy tales, highlighting their narrative choices and impact.
• Narrative Choices: Identify the elements that made these adaptations successful and engaging for a modern audience. This includes character development, plot structure, and thematic exploration.
• Impact and Engagement: Study how successful retellings connected with audiences, considering the use of modern themes and relatable characters.

Balancing Nostalgia with Modernity

Maintaining the spirit of the original while updating it for today's audience requires a delicate balance.

• Respecting Source Material: Respecting the core elements of the original story provides a foundation for the adaptation, adding a layer of familiarity and nostalgia.
• Incorporating Nostalgia: Use elements of nostalgia thoughtfully to attract longtime fans while still making necessary changes for a contemporary storyline.
• Appealing to Both Audiences: The goal should be to create a story that resonates with both longtime fans of the original fairytale and new audiences. Finding that balance is key.

Conclusion

Disney's future approach to Snow White in live-action adaptations presents a vital opportunity to create a powerful and resonant narrative for modern audiences. By proactively addressing the problematic elements of the original, modernizing the story with empowered characters, inclusive casting, and learning from successful retellings, Disney can produce a film that champions strong female leads and resonates deeply. Focusing on creating an empowered Snow White, a complex "Evil Queen," and a story prioritizing agency and self-reliance is crucial for the success of future Snow White adaptations. Let's hope future Snow White adaptations fully embrace these improvements and offer a truly progressive reimagining of this classic fairytale.