Are School Suspensions Doing More Harm Than Good? A Comprehensive Analysis

Omar Yusuf

5 min read

Post on May 02, 2025

4.4

Share

H2: The Negative Impacts of School Suspensions on Student Outcomes

School suspensions, a common disciplinary tool, often have unintended and harmful consequences that outweigh any perceived benefits. The negative impact on student outcomes is significant and far-reaching.

H3: Increased Risk of Academic Failure

Suspensions directly contribute to academic failure. Removing a student from the learning environment disrupts their education, creating a ripple effect that can last for years.

• Lost instructional time: Days or weeks missed due to suspension translate to lost learning opportunities, falling behind peers, and struggling to catch up.
• Difficulty catching up: The missed curriculum and the social and emotional disruption make it exceptionally challenging for suspended students to regain academic ground.
• Negative impact on GPA: Missed assignments, tests, and overall academic performance inevitably lower GPA, affecting college applications and future opportunities.
• Increased likelihood of dropping out: Repeated suspensions often lead to disengagement and alienation from school, increasing the risk of dropping out entirely.

Studies consistently show a strong correlation between suspension rates and lower graduation rates. For instance, a study by the National Education Association found that students with multiple suspensions are significantly more likely to drop out of high school.

H3: Mental Health Consequences

Beyond academic setbacks, school suspensions inflict significant damage on students' mental health. The feeling of exclusion and punishment can exacerbate existing mental health issues or trigger new ones.

• Increased feelings of isolation: Suspension isolates students, separating them from their peers, teachers, and support systems, leading to feelings of loneliness and abandonment.
• Damaged self-esteem: Being suspended often results in a damaged sense of self-worth and confidence, fostering feelings of inadequacy and shame.
• Higher risk of substance abuse: Students who are suspended may turn to drugs or alcohol as coping mechanisms for the stress and isolation they experience.
• Increased likelihood of behavioral problems: Suspension can create a vicious cycle, where the negative experience leads to further behavioral issues and increased disciplinary actions.

Research consistently links suspension to increased rates of anxiety, depression, and other mental health problems. The punitive nature of suspension often fails to address the underlying causes of misbehavior, instead exacerbating the student's emotional distress.

H3: The School-to-Prison Pipeline

Perhaps the most alarming consequence of widespread school suspensions is its contribution to the school-to-prison pipeline. This system disproportionately affects marginalized students, particularly students of color.

• Racial disparities in suspension rates: Data consistently reveals significant racial disparities in school suspension rates, with Black and Hispanic students suspended at far higher rates than their white peers.
• Increased contact with law enforcement: Suspensions often involve contact with law enforcement, leading to a criminal record and further involvement with the justice system.
• Criminalization of childhood misbehavior: Minor infractions that could be handled within the school are instead treated as criminal offenses, leading to lasting consequences.
• Cycle of poverty and incarceration: The school-to-prison pipeline traps students in a cycle of poverty and incarceration, limiting their opportunities and perpetuating systemic inequalities.

The disproportionate impact of suspensions on minority students highlights the need for a more equitable and restorative approach to school discipline.

H2: Alternative Disciplinary Approaches

Rather than relying on punitive measures like suspensions, schools should adopt alternative disciplinary approaches that focus on positive behavior, restorative practices, and addressing the root causes of misbehavior.

H3: Restorative Justice Practices

Restorative justice offers a powerful alternative to suspensions. It focuses on repairing harm caused by misbehavior, involving all stakeholders in a collaborative process.

• Focus on repairing harm: Restorative practices aim to address the impact of wrongdoing on victims and the community, fostering understanding and reconciliation.
• Involving all stakeholders: Students, victims, families, and school staff are involved in the process, promoting shared responsibility and accountability.
• Emphasis on accountability and reconciliation: The focus is on accountability and making amends, rather than simply punishing the offender.
• Improved school climate: Restorative practices contribute to a more positive and supportive school climate, reducing conflict and improving relationships.

Numerous schools have successfully implemented restorative justice programs, demonstrating their effectiveness in reducing suspensions and improving school climate.

H3: Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS)

PBIS is a proactive framework that focuses on preventing disciplinary issues before they arise. It emphasizes positive reinforcement and data-driven decision-making.

• Proactive strategies: PBIS utilizes proactive strategies to create positive school environments and teach students appropriate behaviors.
• Positive reinforcement: The framework focuses on rewarding positive behaviors rather than solely punishing negative ones.
• Data-driven decision-making: Schools use data to identify areas for improvement and evaluate the effectiveness of their interventions.
• Improved student behavior: PBIS has been shown to significantly reduce disciplinary incidents and improve overall student behavior.

Research shows that schools implementing PBIS have significantly lower suspension rates and improved school climate.

H3: Trauma-Informed Approaches

Many students' misbehavior stems from underlying trauma. Trauma-informed approaches prioritize understanding and addressing the impact of trauma on students' behavior.

• Creating safe and supportive environments: Trauma-informed schools create safe and supportive environments where students feel understood and respected.
• Addressing underlying causes of misbehavior: The focus is on identifying and addressing the root causes of students' behavioral challenges, often related to trauma.
• Building relationships with students: Strong relationships between students and educators are essential for fostering trust and support.
• Providing mental health support: Schools provide access to mental health services for students who need it.

Trauma-informed practices help to create a more nurturing and understanding school environment, leading to a significant reduction in disciplinary issues.

3. Conclusion

The evidence overwhelmingly suggests that school suspensions do more harm than good. The negative impacts on student outcomes, mental health, and the perpetuation of the school-to-prison pipeline are significant and far-reaching. Alternative disciplinary strategies, such as restorative justice, PBIS, and trauma-informed approaches, offer more effective and humane ways to address student misbehavior. To create safer and more supportive learning environments for all students, we must move beyond the ineffective and harmful practice of school suspensions and embrace alternative disciplinary strategies that prioritize restorative justice, positive behavior support, and trauma-informed care. Let's work together to find effective school discipline solutions and reduce school suspensions, creating schools where every child can thrive.